Accessibility Tools

  • Content scaling 100%
  • Font size 100%
  • Line height 100%
  • Letter spacing 100%

July 1999, no. 212

Welcome to the July 1999 issue of Australian Book Review

Morag Fraser reviews Why Werent We Told? by Henry Reynolds
Free Article: No
Contents Category: History
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

In November 1998, the Governor General, Sir William Deane, found himself in the centre of a storm over the commemoration of Australia’s Aboriginal dead. Launching historian Ken Inglis’s Sacred Places: War Memorials in the Australian Landscape, Sir William remarked that in a country of more than 4,000 memorials there were none, at least of an official kind, to the Aborigines who had been slaughtered in the ‘Black Wars’ of the colonial period.

Book 1 Title: Why Weren’t We Told?
Book 1 Subtitle: A Personal Search For The Truth About Our History
Book Author: Henry Reynolds
Book 1 Biblio: Viking $24.95pb, 264 pp
Book 1 Readings Link: booktopia.kh4ffx.net/Koevy
Display Review Rating: No

In November 1998, the Governor General, Sir William Deane, found himself in the centre of a storm over the commemoration of Australia’s Aboriginal dead. Launching historian Ken Inglis’s Sacred Places: War Memorials in the Australian Landscape, Sir William remarked that in a country of more than 4,000 memorials there were none, at least of an official kind, to the Aborigines who had been slaughtered in the ‘Black Wars’ of the colonial period.

Read more: Morag Fraser reviews 'Why Weren't We Told?' by Henry Reynolds

Write comment (0 Comments)
Peter Rose reviews Dear B by Jennifer Harrison
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Since the publication in 1995 of her first collection, Michelangelo’s Prisoners, Jennifer Harrison has continued to impress readers and to broaden her repertoire. Her fourth collection in as many years, the intimately entitled Dear B, consolidates her reputation and demonstrates sufficient difference and intensity to satisfy admirers of this sensitive, likeable poet.

Book 1 Title: Dear B
Book Author: Jennifer Harrison
Book 1 Biblio: Black Pepper, $19.95 pb, 68 pp
Display Review Rating: No

Since the publication in 1995 of her first collection, Michelangelo’s Prisoners, Jennifer Harrison has continued to impress readers and to broaden her repertoire. Her fourth collection in as many years, the intimately entitled Dear B, consolidates her reputation and demonstrates sufficient difference and intensity to satisfy admirers of this sensitive, likeable poet.

Read more: Peter Rose reviews 'Dear B' by Jennifer Harrison

Write comment (0 Comments)
Kevin Brophy reviews Too Many Men by Lily Brett
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

There are now 10,000 books written about Auschwitz. About the Holocaust there must be many more tens of thousands. Lily Brett is one of the great readers and collectors of these books. Her novels and poems are awash with Holocaust details and with an obsessive sense of responsibility for this impossible knowledge. Impossible because the horrific details cannot be held in the mind for long. In Too Many Men, the Holocaust stories do not come with the poised and philosophical moral gravity of an Inga Clendinnen, nor with the outrageous sensationalism of a Darville but with a doggedness and astonishment that are finally powerfully effective.

Book 1 Title: Too Many Men
Book Author: Lily Brett
Book 1 Biblio: Picador, $28 pb, 714 pp
Book 1 Readings Link: booktopia.kh4ffx.net/ZddrbQ
Display Review Rating: No

There are now 10,000 books written about Auschwitz. About the Holocaust there must be many more tens of thousands. Lily Brett is one of the great readers and collectors of these books. Her novels and poems are awash with Holocaust details and with an obsessive sense of responsibility for this impossible knowledge. Impossible because the horrific details cannot be held in the mind for long. In Too Many Men, the Holocaust stories do not come with the poised and philosophical moral gravity of an Inga Clendinnen, nor with the outrageous sensationalism of a Darville but with a doggedness and astonishment that are finally powerfully effective.

Too Many Men might be the novel Lily Brett has been trying to write all these years as she produced her earlier three smaller, less ambitious novels. From the outset it promises to be a weighty reprise on the previous novels. I was disappointed at first for the impression was that I had stepped right back into Just Like That (1994), a novel I thought had lacked the brittle edginess of her first two. Long before the end, though, this book won me over.

Read more: Kevin Brophy reviews 'Too Many Men' by Lily Brett

Write comment (0 Comments)
Terri-ann White reviews Happy Families by Susan Varga
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

During my reading of Susan Varga’s first work of fiction, Happy Families, I was drawn back into the fields of family and emotion as offered in the two recent American films: The Ice Storm and Six Degrees of Separation. Each of these works hard at tracking the intricacies of humans connecting and communicating, the tectonics of family and emotional landscapes. Happy Families shows us, up close, mothers and daughters, aunts and grandchildren and cousins, lovers and spouses and neighbours. The drive of the work is, as with the two films cited, about how trauma is carried in the body, how we try and trick ourselves about recoveries. And, to a lesser extent, how we integrate the apprehension of difference into our experience of walking through the world. Varga’s novel is one of restitution and connection.

Book 1 Title: Happy Families
Book Author: Susan Varga
Book 1 Biblio: Hodder Headline Sceptre, $22.95 pb, 267 pp
Display Review Rating: No

During my reading of Susan Varga’s first work of fiction, Happy Families, I was drawn back into the fields of family and emotion as offered in the two recent American films: The Ice Storm and Six Degrees of Separation. Each of these works hard at tracking the intricacies of humans connecting and communicating, the tectonics of family and emotional landscapes. Happy Families shows us, up close, mothers and daughters, aunts and grandchildren and cousins, lovers and spouses and neighbours. The drive of the work is, as with the two films cited, about how trauma is carried in the body, how we try and trick ourselves about recoveries. And, to a lesser extent, how we integrate the apprehension of difference into our experience of walking through the world. Varga’s novel is one of restitution and connection.

On reflection, this became even more pronounced weeks after I had finished the novel. Happy Families has a powerful thread of compassion and works from a basic premise that change is possible, I suppose; while that might sound naïve, it is also accurate in the terms of this book and so I’m sticking with it. Change occurs, is embarked upon, across class and race and generations and sexuality for these characters, and it is always profound.

Read more: Terri-ann White reviews 'Happy Families' by Susan Varga

Write comment (0 Comments)
Peter Craven reviews Collected Poems I 1961-1981 and Collected Poems II 1984-1999 by Peter Porter
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Peter Porter first came to prominence nearly forty years ago as an ironic, tough, rather dandyish poet who wore his Australian expatriatism with a flair and who kept his poetic distance on a London which enthralled and appalled him. He came out with striking lines like ‘I am only the image I can force upon the town’ – all glitter and brittleness – but he was also the kind of poet who could produce the sort of set pieces which seemed to sum up the world of a London which was swinging almost as if it was on a gibbet: ‘All the boys are howling to take the girls to bed’ is the promising opening of ‘John Marston Advises Anger’ which evokes with, yes, sub-Jacobean panache, a time and a place intimately known but still half strange and riddled with the glamour of the stage set, the rhetoric of the nothingness of where it’s at.

Book 1 Title: Collected Poems I 1961-1981
Book Author: Peter Porter
Book 1 Biblio: Oxford University Press, $69.9S pb
Book 2 Title: Collected Poems II 1984-1999
Book 2 Author: Peter Porter
Book 2 Biblio: Oxford University Press, $69.9S pb
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 2 Cover (800 x 1200):
Book 2 Cover Path (no longer required): images/ABR_Digitising_2021/Apr_2021/s-l500.jpg
Display Review Rating: No

Peter Porter first came to prominence nearly forty years ago as an ironic, tough, rather dandyish poet who wore his Australian expatriatism with a flair and who kept his poetic distance on a London which enthralled and appalled him. He came out with striking lines like ‘I am only the image I can force upon the town’ – all glitter and brittleness – but he was also the kind of poet who could produce the sort of set pieces which seemed to sum up the world of a London which was swinging almost as if it was on a gibbet: ‘All the boys are howling to take the girls to bed’ is the promising opening of ‘John Marston Advises Anger’ which evokes with, yes, sub-Jacobean panache, a time and a place intimately known but still half strange and riddled with the glamour of the stage set, the rhetoric of the nothingness of where it’s at.

Read more: Peter Craven reviews 'Collected Poems I 1961-1981' and 'Collected Poems II 1984-1999' by Peter...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Katharine England reviews Shark by Bruce Pascoe
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Figuratively speaking Shark reminds me of a pencil-and-paper game: change FOX into SHARK a letter at a time, so that the stepping-stones of words like the one to the other. For Fox is back, back from the independence struggle in West Papua and retired to Australia and the evocatively named coastal town of Tired Sailor, and by the end of the book Fox has become Shark, elegiacally linked by some of Bruce Pascoe’s most lyrical prose.

Book 1 Title: Shark
Book Author: Bruce Pascoe
Book 1 Biblio: Magabala $16.95pb, 216 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Figuratively speaking Shark reminds me of a pencil-and-paper game: change FOX into SHARK a letter at a time, so that the stepping-stones of words like the one to the other. For Fox is back, back from the independence struggle in West Papua and retired to Australia and the evocatively named coastal town of Tired Sailor, and by the end of the book Fox has become Shark, elegiacally linked by some of Bruce Pascoe’s most lyrical prose.

Read more: Katharine England reviews 'Shark' by Bruce Pascoe

Write comment (0 Comments)
Jennifer Maiden reviews Infinite City: 100 Sonnetinas by Alex Skovron and Aerial Photography by Joanne Burns
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Despite the differences in style, careful logic seems to me to be the prevalent characteristic of both these accomplished poetry collections. Hard-won logic, too. In each, we are made aware often of the processes of achieving intellectual and emotional assessment and balance. As the titles indicate, poem after poem vividly accumulates details to settle on a succinct but more distanced and distancing overview.

Book 1 Title: Infinite City
Book 1 Subtitle: 100 Sonnetinas
Book Author: Alex Skovron
Book 1 Biblio: Five Islands Press, $13.95pb, 103pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Title: Aerial Photography
Book 2 Author: Joanne Burns
Book 2 Biblio: Five Islands Press $12.95pb, 92pp
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 2 Cover (800 x 1200):
Book 2 Cover Path (no longer required): images/ABR_Digitising_2021/Apr_2021/ezgif-1-fbb878d775f3.jpg
Display Review Rating: No

Despite the differences in style, careful logic seems to me to be the prevalent characteristic of both these accomplished poetry collections. Hard-won logic, too. In each, we are made aware often of the processes of achieving intellectual and emotional assessment and balance. As the titles indicate, poem after poem vividly accumulates details to settle on a succinct but more distanced and distancing overview.

Read more: Jennifer Maiden reviews 'Infinite City: 100 Sonnetinas' by Alex Skovron and 'Aerial Photography'...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Display Review Rating: No

Dear Editor,

‘Who reads it?’ asks Gerard Windsor of HEAT (ABR, June 1999) and admits he no longer does. In fact, he confesses, he never reads stories or essays by writers who don’t have a book to their name. What a strange and limiting conceit! But as for who reads HEAT, well, I for one do – every issue, from cover to cover. And there must be more like me; people who read for enjoyment, who read for reasons other than job or duty, who read to please themselves.

I like HEAT. It may be a mélange, but there are few duds in the mix, and patterns and themes can often be glimpsed in the juxtapositioning of writers and text, poems and visuals, allowing pieces to resonate and spark off one another. This is a hallmark of HEAT and evidence of Indyk’s skill as an editor. HEAT is challenging, stimulating, and thought provoking. Few would like everything with equal fervour, and personally I admit that pieces have lost me or left me puzzled. But never bored.

Read more: Letters to the Editor - July 1999

Write comment (0 Comments)
Graham Little reviews Partners edited by Ross Fitzgerald and Anne Henderson
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Interview
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

In Partners, the unstated question is how relationships can last if they are equal – that is if they are free as well as binding. There’s a suggestion that it was easier in the old hetero-patriarchal marriages where our parents accepted inequality and could turn to authority, within and outside the relationship, to see that it lasted. Not that most of the contributors address the question directly. But in the background, there’s the cheerful assumption that getting into partnership, not into marriage, we’re getting into equality as well – an assumption that’s not borne out by the stories we’re told in the book. Maybe we are freer (at least from outside interference) and more equal than we were; but almost every partnership here turns on, is said to turn on, unequal devotion, one partner devoted, the other devotee.

Book 1 Title: Partners
Book Author: Ross Fitzgerald and Anne Henderson
Book 1 Biblio: Harper Collins $19.95 pb, 270 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Editor
Display Review Rating: No

In Partners, the unstated question is how relationships can last if they are equal – that is if they are free as well as binding. There’s a suggestion that it was easier in the old hetero-patriarchal marriages where our parents accepted inequality and could turn to authority, within and outside the relationship, to see that it lasted. Not that most of the contributors address the question directly. But in the background, there’s the cheerful assumption that getting into partnership, not into marriage, we’re getting into equality as well – an assumption that’s not borne out by the stories we’re told in the book. Maybe we are freer (at least from outside interference) and more equal than we were; but almost every partnership here turns on, is said to turn on, unequal devotion, one partner devoted, the other devotee.

Read more: Graham Little reviews 'Partners' edited by Ross Fitzgerald and Anne Henderson

Write comment (0 Comments)
Jeffrey Grey reviews Anzacs, the Media and the Great War by John F. Williams
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Australian History
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

The myth and reality of the Anzac legend has proven a perennial subject of inquiry and argument for over thirty years now, since the publication of Ken Inglis’s justly famous articles in Meanjin and elsewhere in 1964–65. These prompted a spirited exchange with the late Geoff Serle and others. More recently, John Robertson examined the Gallipoli campaign in terms of the myth (1990), and found the critics of Australian martial performance wanting, while Eric Andrews took the Anglo-Australian relationship between 1914 and 1918 to task (1993), and found duplicity and manipulation in the construction of the Australians’ image.

Book 1 Title: Anzacs, the Media and the Great War
Book Author: John F. Williams
Book 1 Biblio: UNSW Press, $35.00 pb, 288 pp
Display Review Rating: No

The myth and reality of the Anzac legend has proven a perennial subject of inquiry and argument for over thirty years now, since the publication of Ken Inglis’s justly famous articles in Meanjin and elsewhere in 1964–65. These prompted a spirited exchange with the late Geoff Serle and others. More recently, John Robertson examined the Gallipoli campaign in terms of the myth (1990), and found the critics of Australian martial performance wanting, while Eric Andrews took the Anglo-Australian relationship between 1914 and 1918 to task (1993), and found duplicity and manipulation in the construction of the Australians’ image.

Read more: Jeffrey Grey reviews 'Anzacs, the Media and the Great War' by John F. Williams

Write comment (0 Comments)
Philippa Hawker reviews Wraith by Lee Tulloch
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Celebrity Stakes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

In the hierarchy of celebrity, there is one group of people constantly referred to with a casual, first-name intimacy. The ‘I don’t get out of bed for less than $10,000 a day’ brigade, the supermodels. Linda and Naomi, Christy and Kate. It’s not that we know anything about them as individuals, nor that they seem any more approachable than any other kind of late twentieth century celebrity. It’s the brand-name simplicity of their fame , the instantly recognisable qualities they incarnate. Recognisable at a glance, they are trademarks, bestowing their signature style on garments, products, publications, and boyfriends.

Book 1 Title: Wraith
Book Author: Lee Tulloch
Book 1 Biblio: $19.95 pb, 503 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

In the hierarchy of celebrity, there is one group of people constantly referred to with a casual, first-name intimacy. The ‘I don’t get out of bed for less than $10,000 a day’ brigade, the supermodels. Linda and Naomi, Christy and Kate. It’s not that we know anything about them as individuals, nor that they seem any more approachable than any other kind of late twentieth century celebrity. It’s the brand-name simplicity of their fame , the instantly recognisable qualities they incarnate. Recognisable at a glance, they are trademarks, bestowing their signature style on garments, products, publications, and boyfriends.

Lee Tulloch’s new novel, Wraith, is set in this world of expensive, fleeting hypervisibility. The title character is Berenger, a wildly successful young model known in the trade as The Wraith. At fifteen, we are told, she caused a sensation on the couture runways of Paris, replacing the previous modelling phenomenon, a fragile and forlorn creature known as The Waif. The New York Times noted of Berenger that ‘fashion spectators can’t get enough of her, the way she rambles down the runway taking three times as long as any other model and stops, dazed, in front of the photographers, while the other models pile up behind her’. Designer Karl Lagerfeld praised her ‘very fresh look … Not this victim look at all. Very romantic, I would say. And a bit scary, you know, like she should be locked up in a mental asylum. It’s very dangerous, very modern.’

Read more: Philippa Hawker reviews 'Wraith' by Lee Tulloch

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Theatre
Custom Article Title: Rolling Column
Review Article: No
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

On my desk lies a review copy of Leah Purcell and Scott Rankin’s play, Box the Pony, which comes as a particularly lavish edition put out by Hodder, not a name usually associated with Australian play publishing, let alone anything as new as this. The review appears elsewhere in ABR, but I was surprised at being asked to offer a critique of it at all. Productions get reviewed, but once in print plays tend to be ignored – at least in Australia. Why, I asked ABR’s editor, shifting the phone to the other ear in expectation of a lengthy discussion. There was a pause. Because Australian plays don’t often appear in print, she said, a bit puzzled at having to state the obvious. When I began to splutter a defence she handed me this column, effectively challenging me to prove plays on the page are out there and argue convincingly that a literary journal of review should assist in readjusting the half-frames of the literati in order to pull the published play into focus.

Display Review Rating: No

On my desk lies a review copy of Leah Purcell and Scott Rankin’s play, Box the Pony, which comes as a particularly lavish edition put out by Hodder, not a name usually associated with Australian play publishing, let alone anything as new as this. The review appears elsewhere in ABR, but I was surprised at being asked to offer a critique of it at all. Productions get reviewed, but once in print plays tend to be ignored – at least in Australia. Why, I asked ABR’s editor, shifting the phone to the other ear in expectation of a lengthy discussion. There was a pause. Because Australian plays don’t often appear in print, she said, a bit puzzled at having to state the obvious. When I began to splutter a defence she handed me this column, effectively challenging me to prove plays on the page are out there and argue convincingly that a literary journal of review should assist in readjusting the half-frames of the literati in order to pull the published play into focus.

There are only two dedicated publishers of any substance active at the moment – Currency Press in Sydney and Playlab Press in Brisbane. Yackandandah Playscripts, long the champion of Melbourne’s playwrights and determinedly in opposition to its big brother in Sydney, seems to have faded out. Vale all those Pramfactory and La Mama experimental pieces Jeff Fiddes so loved. Currency’s 1999 catalogue offers six volumes of Australian plays from the 1960s and 1970s with collections from the 1930s, 1940s, 1950s, and 1980s promised, most of them plays not previously published. This new publications list also includes a six-pack of La Mama plays from the 1990s, a collection of plays seen as feminist, two trilogies, and twenty-two single plays, most of them in the program-insert edition put out for premiers at Playbox. There is a screen play trilogy, two single scripts, and two more in preparation. The general in-print list includes one hundred and eighty-six single plays, collections of Patrick White, Dorothy Hewett, David Williamson, and, curiously, Jim McNeil, Ray Lawler’s Doll trilogy, twenty-three plays for teenagers, fourteen for children, and eight edited play anthologies. And this is not to mention the out-of-print, of which I am one. There is also a separate overlapping catalogue of twenty­nine plays on Aboriginal subjects. In contrast the only other dedicated play publisher, Playlab, has eighty-eight titles in all lists.

Which plays get into these lists and which are left out in the cold is for the publisher and editor, Katherine Brisbane, former theatre critic for The Australian to decide. That is her right, but Currency’s near monopoly of the field means that those who are left out have nowhere to go that can offer them anything like the same distribution, let alone the same public profile. With offshore theatrical interests now sniffing about looking at what we do best, this means that unless you are published by Currency you have little chance of being seen where it now begins to count.

The Hodder publication, rare and welcome though it is, looks like an updated version of the Old Heinemann’s educational series. Carefully packaged essays and explanatory material designed to make the study of the plays easier for teachers and students presumably make such editions cost effective. Currency and Playlab are already marketing similar work. Which cannot help but take the business of play publishing out of the theatre and into the schoolroom and put the playwright at the mercy of teenage and education interests. The pull these interests now exert on companies and playwrights is growing. No bad thing, if it was matched by a continuing interest once the young turn into GP audiences who buy play text programs at the theatre door. The trouble is that these audiences seldom read what they buy. Audience information sessions run by many of the theatres make this quite clear.

The reason for tossing the text into the family collection of souvenirs rather than putting it on the bedside table is not so clear. It could be because the buyer sees play reading as kids’ stuff or has not had the benefit of a play-reading education and has neither the time nor the inclination to acquire it from theatre companies or summer courses. Seeing a single performance of the play with the program used in the interval as a guide to who plays whom is as far as it goes. It could be because book clubs and reading groups are not matched by theatre parties formed from play reading groups. My own view is that until the literary establishment recognises the play text as a literary artefact this will continue to be the case. Look at the now misnamed writers’ festivals where publishing interests over­shadow those of the literati and in which as a consequence debate is kept politely muted. Playwrights focus on today’s issues, social and political, and even literary, god help them, but they are seldom heard in these events. Puzzled organising committees find no book sales potential in them and usually suggest a play reading instead as an entertaining aside to the main stage, housed off-venue, damned by faint praise. Until plays are seen to have a value as relevant texts and given serious review status playwrights will continue to be kept on the margins of public debate in this way. What a waste.

Write comment (0 Comments)
Deborah Zion reviews The Womans Power Handbook by Joan Kirner and Moira Rayner
Free Article: No
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Women and the power game
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

What do women want and how can they get it? These questions were at the heart of second wave feminism. The Women’s Power Handbook focuses on the second of these queries. The idea for the book was born when Moira Rayner and Joan Kirner met touring Victoria with Naomi Wolfe. On their travels they were struck by the questions that young women asked. Most of these related to practical issues about power. How to get it and, more important, how to use it without compromising integrity. According to the authors, no feminist tracts were providing young women with the answers that they needed, and this is what they set out to do in The Women’s Power Handbook.

Book 1 Title: The Woman’s Power Handbook
Book Author: by Joan Kirner and Moira Rayner
Book 1 Biblio: Viking, $24.95 pb, 326 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

What do women want and how can they get it? These questions were at the heart of second wave feminism. The Women’s Power Handbook focuses on the second of these queries. The idea for the book was born when Moira Rayner and Joan Kirner met touring Victoria with Naomi Wolfe. On their travels they were struck by the questions that young women asked. Most of these related to practical issues about power. How to get it and, more important, how to use it without compromising integrity. According to the authors, no feminist tracts were providing young women with the answers that they needed, and this is what they set out to do in The Women’s Power Handbook.

Read more: Deborah Zion reviews 'The Woman's Power Handbook' by Joan Kirner and Moira Rayner

Write comment (0 Comments)
On the Park Bench by Edmund Campion
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Essay
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: On the Park Bench
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

You know you are getting old when one of your students, genuine in her puzzlement, says to you, ‘Who was Bob Santamaria?’ Santamaria? The most famous lay Catholic since Ned Kelly! The man whose machine split Australian Catholicism for a generation; whose politics kept Labor from office for two decades; whose disciples and friends still move through the corridors of power in church and state! To meet someone to whom Santamaria is an unfamiliar name is to know that you too will soon be history.

Display Review Rating: No

You know you are getting old when one of your students, genuine in her puzzlement, says to you, ‘Who was Bob Santamaria?’ Santamaria? The most famous lay Catholic since Ned Kelly! The man whose machine split Australian Catholicism for a generation; whose politics kept Labor from office for two decades; whose disciples and friends still move through the corridors of power in church and state! To meet someone to whom Santamaria is an unfamiliar name is to know that you too will soon be history.

Read more: 'On the Park Bench' by Edmund Campion

Write comment (0 Comments)
Michael Costigan reviews Collateral Damage by Geoff Page
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Impressive Volume
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

As with the dozen or so collections of Geoff Page’s poetry that have preceded it over almost thirty years, Collateral Damage can be opened at random with the certainty that something impressive will be there. One of the most striking characteristics of his published work is its consistent high quality.

Book 1 Title: Collateral Damage
Book Author: Geoff Page
Book 1 Biblio: Indigo $18 pb, 104 pp
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

As with the dozen or so collections of Geoff Page’s poetry that have preceded it over almost thirty years, Collateral Damage can be opened at random with the certainty that something impressive will be there. One of the most striking characteristics of his published work is its consistent high quality.

A feature of Collateral Damage is the immediacy of the social comment in a number of the poems, the longest of which is ‘Guns’. While it was occasioned by the mad slaughter of small schoolchildren m Dunblane, Scotland, several years ago its message has an urgent if unheeded relevance to the subsequent mass killings in American schools. After itemising his own youthful familiarity with numerous firearms, the poet concludes:

Read more: Michael Costigan reviews 'Collateral Damage' by Geoff Page

Write comment (0 Comments)
Jane Messer reviews Wilde Eve – Eve Langley’s Story edited by Lucy Frost
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Biography
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Eve Langley Revisited
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

On a day which began with Eve finding her children ‘half naked and purple with cold … crying on their bed’, she was visited by a detective. He was there to ask questions because ‘La Gauss’, the old woman who let rooms to the family, had accused Eve’s husband of stealing. Langley let him know that she wrote everything down, including all of La Gauss’s lies, and that she would one day make a book of it. He is surprised that she could write of her life in these parts, and waves ‘his hand toward the ferns and gorse on the hill outside’. Eve replied, ‘The tragedy of life down here would amaze you. I have everything down sympathetically, and someday it shall be published.’

Book 1 Title: Wilde Eve
Book 1 Subtitle: Eve Langley’s Story
Book Author: Lucy Frost
Book 1 Biblio: Vintage, $18.95 pb, 322 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Editor
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

On a day which began with Eve finding her children ‘half naked and purple with cold … crying on their bed’, she was visited by a detective. He was there to ask questions because ‘La Gauss’, the old woman who let rooms to the family, had accused Eve’s husband of stealing. Langley let him know that she wrote everything down, including all of La Gauss’s lies, and that she would one day make a book of it. He is surprised that she could write of her life in these parts, and waves ‘his hand toward the ferns and gorse on the hill outside’. Eve replied, ‘The tragedy of life down here would amaze you. I have everything down sympathetically, and someday it shall be published.’

And she was half right. Except for poems and other short works Langley’s ten books about her life in New Zealand were not published – until now. Lucy Frost has edited seven of the Mitchell Library manuscripts, reducing just under 3000 pages to 300 odd. And what a fabulous job she’s done. Frost has rectified the balance on Eve Langley which Joy L. Thwaite in her 1989 (in most ways excellent) biography The Importance of Being Eve Langley had weighted towards Eve the blighted genius, pathetic mad Eve, self-destructive Eve.

Read more: Jane Messer reviews 'Wilde Eve – Eve Langley’s Story' edited by Lucy Frost

Write comment (0 Comments)
Peter Edwards reviews Breaking the Codes: Australia’s KGB Network 1944-1950 by Desmond Ball & David Horner
Free Article: No
Contents Category: History
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: The Cold War
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Breaking The Codes was published last August. The time that has subsequently elapsed makes it possible to comment not only on the book itself but also on some aspects of its reception.

Book 1 Title: Breaking the Codes
Book 1 Subtitle: Australia’s KGB Network 1944-1950
Book Author: Desmond Ball & David Horner
Book 1 Biblio: Allen & Unwin, $29.95 pb, 469 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Breaking The Codes was published last August. The time that has subsequently elapsed makes it possible to comment not only on the book itself but also on some aspects of its reception.

For most Australians interested in current affairs and recent history, Desmond Ball and David Horner are familiar names but at first sight unlikely joint authors. Both have published extensively and authoritatively. Ball is best known for his books on intelligence matters, including the joint Australian-American facilities at Pine Gap and Nurrungar and other aspects of the world of signals intelligence. Horner is similarly well known for a number of major books on Australian strategy and military politics, especially during the 1939–45 war. They have in common reputations for enormously detailed knowledge, based on extensive and thorough research.

What makes them seem unlikely collaborators, despite their being colleagues in the Strategic and Defence Studies Centre at the Australian National University, is the difference in their political associations. During the Vietnam War, Ball was a prominent protester whose position was not far from that of the Communist Party, while Horner commanded an Australian army platoon in Vietnam. Ball’s publications on intelligence matters have often revealed what the defence establishment wanted to keep secret, while Horner remains closely associated with the Australian Army. These differences are in fact a source of strength and credibility for the book, which touches on some of the most contentious political aspects of Australia’s involvement in the Cold War. Ever since the 1954 election, fought in the shadow of the Petrov Affair, one school of opinion has refused to accept the legitimacy of its result. According to this school, the Petrov Affair was a fraud; the allegations of a pro-Soviet spy ring in Australia were manufactured or highly exaggerated; and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) was from the start an unnecessary form of political police, operating in the interests of the conservative parties and Australia’s great power allies.

Read more: Peter Edwards reviews 'Breaking the Codes: Australia’s KGB Network 1944-1950' by Desmond Ball &...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Reviews
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Cabaret Volume
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Alan Gould is not noted for being a poet of light verse, but with this volume he has achieved what brewers of light beer aim for strength without the hangover. The blurb rightly highlights Gould’s technique and lyrical gifts, and his acute vision of absurdity is present in abundance. Perhaps Gould has become the Heinrich Heine of Canberra, charting his city of decadence, with its down-and-outs, retired Army Majors, cheap opiates and X-rated entertainments, its dandified lobbyists, ‘Tsarevnas-on-the-dole’ and divorcees desperate for dalliance. Anne Langridge’s illustrations add to the book’s cabaret atmosphere, though you wouldn’t say Gould was paying homage to Berlin’s in the 1930s, with its Dada and expressionist camp.

Book 1 Title: Dalliance and Scorn
Book Author: by Alan Gould with drawings by Anne Langridge
Book 1 Biblio: Indigo Press, 84 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Alan Gould is not noted for being a poet of light verse, but with this volume he has achieved what brewers of light beer aim for strength without the hangover. The blurb rightly highlights Gould’s technique and lyrical gifts, and his acute vision of absurdity is present in abundance. Perhaps Gould has become the Heinrich Heine of Canberra, charting his city of decadence, with its down-and-outs, retired Army Majors, cheap opiates and X-rated entertainments, its dandified lobbyists, ‘Tsarevnas-on-the-dole’ and divorcees desperate for dalliance. Anne Langridge’s illustrations add to the book’s cabaret atmosphere, though you wouldn’t say Gould was paying homage to Berlin’s in the 1930s, with its Dada and expressionist camp.

For a committed free-verser like myself, Gould’s grasp of traditional verse form is dazzling – form as a ludic performance, a virtuoso doing a Paganini. Perhaps this is a ludicrous book for all that, and occasionally, an over-use of iambic pentameters sounds wrong, as in poems inspired by Jazz; I prefer the more vernacular breath of the Black American poet Komunyakaa, or the New Yorker Kleinzahler. What Gould has though, is the knowledge of Old and Middle English rhyme schemes, and its alliteration and sprezzatura sound effects: ‘Bees are pestering sparaxis’ for example. Metaphorical inventions abound. In one poem, the moon is compared to a topaz, a briolette, a ‘little gizmo’ earring and a ‘whitefaced, puffy, balding bloke’.

Read more: Adam Aitken reviews 'Dalliance and Scorn' by Alan Gould with drawings by Anne Langridge

Write comment (0 Comments)
Catherine Ford reviews The Layers of the City by Antoni Jach
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: A Peculiar Vigilance
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

An unnamed visitor and note taker wanders present day Paris in Antoni Jach’s new novel, researching something about the city’s ‘many layers’. This amorphous and arduous quest brings him to a certain library where, while he is waiting for a book on aboveground Paris to be retrieved, a spirited American woman tries to draw him out on his work and why he’s in Paris. He airily responds that his interest lies not only in the city’s underground layers but ‘the buildings and the ether’. He’s remote and strangely earnest yet she’s keen to meet him again, whereas he ‘feels like a barbarian’ in her company and is too neurotically preoccupied with some other kind of engage­ment, an exchange with history, to flirt.

Book 1 Title: The Layers of the City
Book Author: Antoni Jach
Book 1 Biblio: Sceptre, $19.95 pb, 272 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Display Review Rating: No

An unnamed visitor and note taker wanders present day Paris in Antoni Jach’s new novel, researching something about the city’s ‘many layers’. This amorphous and arduous quest brings him to a certain library where, while he is waiting for a book on aboveground Paris to be retrieved, a spirited American woman tries to draw him out on his work and why he’s in Paris. He airily responds that his interest lies not only in the city’s underground layers but ‘the buildings and the ether’. He’s remote and strangely earnest yet she’s keen to meet him again, whereas he ‘feels like a barbarian’ in her company and is too neurotically preoccupied with some other kind of engage­ment, an exchange with history, to flirt.

Read more: Catherine Ford reviews 'The Layers of the City' by Antoni Jach

Write comment (0 Comments)
Mike Smith reviews The Riches of Ancient Australia: An indispensable guide for exploring prehistoric Australia by Josephine Flood
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Australian History
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Ancient Wonders
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Last year I took my twelve-year-old daughter to see Lake Mungo. We talked all morning about ancient lakes and Aboriginal camp sites but looking at the saltbush she could not make the jump. Standing on the lunette, her keen eyes picked out a tiny crenulated piece of bone amongst the drift sand. Less than ten millimetres long it was a fish otolith, part of the bony structure of the inner ear, its shape characteristic of golden perch. Puzzled she looked around at the dry plain and started to ask, ‘How did a fish get way out here?’. Watching her eyes, I saw the flash of understanding: an ancient lake full of water snapped into focus. The tiny otolith was tangible evidence of past environments no book could match. But to grasp the past imaginatively and intellectually you need to visit the sites and learn to read the landscapes. This is part of the reason I like the latest edition of The Riches of Ancient Australia, Josephine Flood’s field guide to prehistoric Australia. It encourages people to get out and look around.

Book 1 Title: The Riches of Ancient Australia
Book 1 Subtitle: An indispensable guide for exploring prehistoric Australia
Book Author: Josephine Flood
Book 1 Biblio: University of Queensland Press, $39.95 pb, 382 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Display Review Rating: No

Last year I took my twelve-year-old daughter to see Lake Mungo. We talked all morning about ancient lakes and Aboriginal camp sites but looking at the saltbush she could not make the jump. Standing on the lunette, her keen eyes picked out a tiny crenulated piece of bone amongst the drift sand. Less than ten millimetres long it was a fish otolith, part of the bony structure of the inner ear, its shape characteristic of golden perch. Puzzled she looked around at the dry plain and started to ask, ‘How did a fish get way out here?’. Watching her eyes, I saw the flash of understanding: an ancient lake full of water snapped into focus. The tiny otolith was tangible evidence of past environments no book could match. But to grasp the past imaginatively and intellectually you need to visit the sites and learn to read the landscapes. This is part of the reason I like the latest edition of The Riches of Ancient Australia, Josephine Flood’s field guide to prehistoric Australia. It encourages people to get out and look around.

Read more: Mike Smith reviews 'The Riches of Ancient Australia: An indispensable guide for exploring...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Philip Morrissey reviews Shadow Child by Rosalie Fraser
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Memoir
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Levels of abuse
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Rosalie Fraser, a two-year-old Aboriginal child, is taken from her family by Child Welfare authorities and fostered with a distant relation of her non-Aboriginal father. She suffers years of abuse at the hands of her foster mother. Occasionally she runs away but her foster mother is always able to charm her into returning. She finally leaves for good when she meets a young man named Stan whom she later marries. In her mid-twenties a gynaecological operation which becomes unexpectedly complicated and painful causes flashbacks of the abuse she endured as a child and she realises she has to confront her past. She writes Shadow Child and in conclusion recommends writing as a therapy for anyone ‘who has problems to come to terms with’.

Book 1 Title: Shadow Child
Book Author: Rosalie Fraser
Book 1 Biblio: Hale & Iremonger, $16.95 pb, 270 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

Rosalie Fraser, a two-year-old Aboriginal child, is taken from her family by Child Welfare authorities and fostered with a distant relation of her non-Aboriginal father. She suffers years of abuse at the hands of her foster mother. Occasionally she runs away but her foster mother is always able to charm her into returning. She finally leaves for good when she meets a young man named Stan whom she later marries. In her mid-twenties a gynaecological operation which becomes unexpectedly complicated and painful causes flashbacks of the abuse she endured as a child and she realises she has to confront her past. She writes Shadow Child and in conclusion recommends writing as a therapy for anyone ‘who has problems to come to terms with’.

Read more: Philip Morrissey reviews 'Shadow Child' by Rosalie Fraser

Write comment (0 Comments)
Michael McGirr reviews The Secret Life of Money: Exposing the private parts of personal money by Valerie Wilson
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Psychology
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: The Root of All Secrets
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

I wouldn’t have minded being a fly on the wall when Valerie Wilson did the research for this book. It began life as a PhD project in the University of Melbourne’s Business School. Wilson wanted to find out what underlying attitude people had to money. She should have asked me. I love the stuff. Just don’t see enough of it.

Book 1 Title: The Secret Life of Money
Book 1 Subtitle: Exposing the private parts of personal money
Book Author: Valerie Wilson
Book 1 Biblio: Allen & Unwin, $19.95pb, 224 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

I wouldn’t have minded being a fly on the wall when Valerie Wilson did the research for this book. It began life as a PhD project in the University of Melbourne’s Business School. Wilson wanted to find out what underlying attitude people had to money. She should have asked me. I love the stuff. Just don’t see enough of it.

Read more: Michael McGirr reviews 'The Secret Life of Money: Exposing the private parts of personal money' by...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Stephen Matthews reviews The View from Ararat by Brian Caswell and Go and Come Back by Joan Abelove
Free Article: No
Contents Category: YA Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Other Worlds
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

For a reviewer, there’s always a temptation to seek a link when writing about more than one book at a time. In this instance, the link, if there is one, is that both these novels for young adults attempt to recreate other worlds, albeit in one case an imagined one, in the other a ‘real’ one. In other respects, however, they could hardly be more different. One credits its readers with intelligence and stamina, the other condescends to them.

Book 1 Title: The View from Ararat
Book Author: Brian Caswell
Book 1 Biblio: UQP $14.90 pb, 268 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Book 2 Title: Go and Come Back
Book 2 Author: Joan Abelove
Book 2 Biblio: Allen & Unwin $14.90 pb, 177 pp
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 2 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

For a reviewer, there’s always a temptation to seek a link when writing about more than one book at a time. In this instance, the link, if there is one, is that both these novels for young adults attempt to recreate other worlds, albeit in one case an imagined one, in the other a ‘real’ one. In other respects, however, they could hardly be more different. One credits its readers with intelligence and stamina, the other condescends to them.

Read more: Stephen Matthews reviews 'The View from Ararat' by Brian Caswell and 'Go and Come Back' by Joan...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Bronwen Douglas reviews Possessions: Indigenous Art/Colonial Culture by Nicholas Thomas
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Indigenous Studies
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Intimate Antagonism
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Nick Thomas is arguably the outstanding academic of international repute at present working in the humanities and social sciences in Australia, as attested by his receipt of the 1998 Royal Anthropological Institute’s Rivers Memorial Medal for exceptional achievement of publications’. He is certainly prolific: Possessions is his eighth single-authored scholarly book in thirteen years. Thomas’ work is eclectic in discipline, interests and style. His themes range from Pacific history to anthropological theory, to postcolonial cultural history and critique, to art. The ambiguous intersections of local and colonial histories and cultures are a persistent concern, with increasing focus on material objects and the visual. He is equally adept with academic arcana as with a prose style directed to that publisher’s ideal, the educated non-specialist.

Book 1 Title: Possessions
Book 1 Subtitle: Indigenous Art/Colonial Culture
Book Author: Nicholas Thomas
Book 1 Biblio: Thames and Hudson, $39.95 pb, 304 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Display Review Rating: No

Nick Thomas is arguably the outstanding academic of international repute at present working in the humanities and social sciences in Australia, as attested by his receipt of the 1998 Royal Anthropological Institute’s Rivers Memorial Medal for exceptional achievement of publications’. He is certainly prolific: Possessions is his eighth single-authored scholarly book in thirteen years. Thomas’ work is eclectic in discipline, interests and style. His themes range from Pacific history to anthropological theory, to postcolonial cultural history and critique, to art. The ambiguous intersections of local and colonial histories and cultures are a persistent concern, with increasing focus on material objects and the visual. He is equally adept with academic arcana as with a prose style directed to that publisher’s ideal, the educated non-specialist.

Read more: Bronwen Douglas reviews 'Possessions: Indigenous Art/Colonial Culture' by Nicholas Thomas

Write comment (0 Comments)
Pam Macintyre reviews Joy Ride by Tony Shillitoe and Straggler’s Reef by Elaine Forrestal
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Children's and Young Adult Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Time Frames
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

One story about a young disaffected male, and another about a sacrificial female, typify the extremes of the range of material currently being published for young people. Straggler’s Reef, for the younger end of the readership, is a conventional story of the past intersecting with the present to resolve events in both time frames. Karri, her brother Jarrad, and their father are sailing off the coast of Western Australia when a squall lands them on a reef. Karri has her grandmother’s recently completed family history to occupy her. The recount of events in the 1840s is engrossing and evocative, and made this reader long for a straight historical novel.

Book 1 Title: Joy Ride
Book Author: Tony Shillitoe
Book 1 Biblio: Wakefield Press, $16.95pb, 160pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 2 Title: Straggler’s Reef
Book 2 Author: Elaine Forrestal
Book 2 Biblio: FACP, $12.95pb, 120pp
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Display Review Rating: No

One story about a young disaffected male, and another about a sacrificial female, typify the extremes of the range of material currently being published for young people. Straggler’s Reef, for the younger end of the readership, is a conventional story of the past intersecting with the present to resolve events in both time frames. Karri, her brother Jarrad, and their father are sailing off the coast of Western Australia when a squall lands them on a reef. Karri has her grandmother’s recently completed family history to occupy her. The recount of events in the 1840s is engrossing and evocative, and made this reader long for a straight historical novel.

Read more: Pam Macintyre reviews 'Joy Ride' by Tony Shillitoe and 'Straggler’s Reef' by Elaine Forrestal

Write comment (0 Comments)