- Free Article: No
- Contents Category: Essay Collection
- Review Article: Yes
- Online Only: No
- Custom Highlight Text:
'Ours is a time when monstrous book-merchandising conglomerates ... are into readers like humpbacks into plankton.’ So thunders James Grieve in the third of fifteen essays in the slim but satisfying When Books Die. All respond to the title, the ‘subordinate clause premising a prediction’. The consensus here is that the book is unkillable, but Grieve looks on the dark side. Swatting a mosquito will never eradicate the fever, he writes. ‘The lethal virus nourished in the putrid medium of The Protocols of the Elders of Zion continues to flourish and kill ...’ If he could, Grieve would eradicate the works of Nostradamus, Gibran and David Irving. He mounts a powerful case for the crime of ‘perverting the course of truth’ to be entered into our statutes.
- Book 1 Title: When Books Die
- Book 1 Subtitle: 15 Essays
- Book 1 Biblio: Finlay Lloyd, $25 pb, 149 pp
- Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
- Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
The one requirement the fifteen contributors – book and literary editors, publishers, translators, printers, poets and novelists – were ‘required to adhere to’ was that they ‘sound like themselves’. This is the overwhelming strength of the book, and its one occasional solipsistic weakness. The first few essays set out to thwart our expectation and to warn us to stay on our toes. Ingeborg Hansen records her deliciously crotchety responses to shoppers in her bookshop. But is this a jape? Can we believe in the ‘thirty-something, extra blonde, extra make-up’ customer who shops for Sartre and Descartes while her ‘hubby’ sits in a V8 ute outside?
Jean Beck’s aggravating and inspiring essay, which follows, is the most problematic of the lot. It is dense but unreliable. Other writers fear the death of taste, imagination and critical thinking more than they fear the loss of the book as artefact. The most personal essays (by Ashley Hay, Rosemary Sorensen, Bruce Sims) are among the best. While neither opposing nor resisting technological evolution, retired publisher Andrew Schuller reckons he would miss book fairs. They would miss him too.
Comments powered by CComment