Accessibility Tools

  • Content scaling 100%
  • Font size 100%
  • Line height 100%
  • Letter spacing 100%
Bec Kavanagh reviews Black Spring by Alison Croggon
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Young Adult Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Lina is part witch, part royalty. Her existence is scorned by both the king and the powerful wizards that all but rule the bitter lands of the North. The story of her heady romance and tragic fate is the centrepiece for Alison Croggon’s latest fiction, a Gothic fantasy inspired by Wuthering Heights.

Book 1 Title: Black Spring
Book Author: Alison Croggon
Book 1 Biblio: Walker Books, $22.95 pb, 286 pp, 9781921977480
Display Review Rating: No

Lina is fierce, wilful, and unrelenting when it comes to getting her own way. She is the character around which others are driven to madness, obsession, and death. Selfish, beautiful, and captivating, we see Lina mainly through the eyes of her maid and once milk-sister Anna. Although Oskar Hammel, a curious visitor to the village, is the catalyst that sparks the telling of the story, Anna is the true narrator, and it is through her that we learn of the complex tragedies surrounding both Lina and the household.

Anna herself is an interesting character, not unfamiliar to suffering. Sadly, the story often pivots so tightly around Lina that our glimpses of Anna’s life, and the workings of a village run by the politics of kings and wizards, are over all too soon as she is summoned in one way or another back to Lina’s side.

Despite the efforts that have clearly gone into the world-building aspects of Black Spring, too much space is devoted to lengthy descriptions and explanations in what is essentially quite a short book.It is clear that Croggon has come up with a story that is rich and beautifully complicated, layered with intriguing politics, told by well-crafted characters. The fault of this book isn’t that it’s bad, but that it is far too compact and the balance between description and action has been lost. Ultimately, Black Spring gives readers only a taste of what could have been a gripping and sinister read.

Comments powered by CComment